I confess I can’t remember. When I reject something, I usually forget all about it. I have too small a mind to keep much more – well, consciously – than I want to remember. I suspect that most contemporary “New Yorker” poets would leave me longing for a V8.
Yes, of course, everything is taste. The trouble with just saying that, though, is that it leaves Mr. A free, in his column in the New York Review of Books, to declare something wonderfully worthy even if it’s clearly junk, so long as he’s respected among the “in” people and, in turn, respects them. By far the best thing someone who cares deeply about art can do, I suppose, is to sync his thinking with that of the right crowd.